
(first published on the internet at: http://www.xiffi.com/index.php/travel/378-travel-newyork/156-the-flying-rat )
by Andrew Arnett
Pigeons have been getting a bad rap lately from City Hall. One Council Member in particular, by the name of Simcha Felder has it out for our feathered friends. He’s gone to great lengths in this regard and has even published a legislative report entitled Curbing the Pigeon Conundrum. In this report Council Member Felder proposes policy recommendations intended to reduce the pigeon population in the city of New York by utilizing hawks for killing pigeons, imposing a $1000 fine on people caught feeding the birds, and interfering with their reproductive systems by way of pigeon birth control pills.
This was a hard pill for me to swallow when I first read about it in the Daily News, and for a moment there I thought I was reading The Onion. But this was reality and later, on the local TV news was Felder again, surrounded by an entourage, giving a press conference on the evils of the flying rat, and the necessity to rid society of the winged vermin. He proposed himself the new Pigeon Czar. It felt like a new dawn was rising in New York City. There are lots of problems in our town, and murder was just one of them, but at least we were going to get the pigeon issue licked. I should have felt some kind of hope but in fact it rather put me off my breakfast, so I left that and went outside for a walk instead.
Outside, on the streets of New York, I walked by a few pigeons. They were pecking at the hard cement. They didn’t seem too threatening to me, and not at all as diseased as some of the bags of puss carrying themselves around on two legs and in business suits. In fact, they exuded a calm quiet dignity which I found inspiring. In some small way, those birds cheered me up. So what if I tossed them a few crumbs of bread once in a rare while. What harm would that bring? Then I thought of Simcha Felder. Heir Simcha Felder, who would like to slap a $1000 dollar fine on me for a mere act of kindness. What the fuck kind of bug crawled up his ass? It seemed stupid, but in light of all the stupidity we are faced with on a daily basis, it seemed to make some brutal sense. Besides, what could I do about it? It was my day off after all, and the Giants were playing the Cowboys on TV, and the hope of seeing the Cowboys get mauled was enough to get me through the day.
I didn’t think much about the pigeon thing for the rest of the week but last Saturday morning as I was watching NY 1 News, I got word that there would be a rally at noon in front of City Hall in protest of Felder’s anti-pigeon proposals. I decided to grab my camera and head on down to see what kind of people would show up.
There were about fifty people gathered in front of City Hall with banners and speakers at a podium, as well as members of the press. There were representatives from PETA, City Wildlife Alliance, Urban Wildlife Coalition, and others.
One speaker stated “do you want your taxes to go up, of course not. Think about it we’re now going to have a pigeon czar. Let’s assume that’s an assistant commissioner and that is $100,000 a year plus benefits. Commissioner has to have a couple of assistants and secretaries. We’re looking at three quarters of a million dollars by the time you pay salary and benefits. This is just to staff the office now you want to feed these birds everyday during the breeding season which for pigeons is 365 days per year with O Vatrol P (to maintain birth control) and the preliminary best guess is about $600,000 per year.
There were a lot of angry people about and lots of flyers being passed around. One flyer explained how a pigeon named Cher Ami won the Congressional Medal of Honor during World War 2 by saving 8000 allied troops and 100,000 civilians after the US artillery began unleashing a massive artillery attack on the U.S. Army’s 77th Division after the battalion got trapped behind enemy lines. A soldier attached a message to their carrier pigeon that read “Our artillery is dropping a barrage on us. For heaven’s sake, stop it!”
A historical account of the incident by the writer Andrew Blechman in his book Pigeons: The Fascinating Saga of the World’s Most Revered and Reviled Bird reads “the soldier uncupped his hands and watched the bird flap its wings and gain altitude. The Germans also saw the pigeon and trained their rifles on it. A hail of bullets whizzed through the air and several hit Cher Ami. He quickly lost altitude and plummeted toward the ground. But moments before crashing, the bird somehow managed to spread his wings again and start climbing, higher and higher, until he was out of rifle range. Twenty minutes later and back on friendly terrain, Cher Ami landed at headquarters. A soldier ran to the bird and found him lying on its back, covered in blood. One eye and part of the cranium had been blown away , and its breast had been ripped open. A silver canister containing the Lost Battalion’s desperate plea dangled from a few tendons – all that remained of the birds severed leg. Bewildered, the soldier rushed the message to his commanding officer. The American artillery fell silent, and the last remains of the Lost Battalion were saved. The stuffed tattered remains of Cher Ami can be seen today , still standing on one leg, at the Smithsonian Institute in Washington, D.C.”
After the last speaker I wandered off from the crowd, looking about the area to see if I could spot any pigeons but I couldn’t spot a single bird. Maybe they got wind of Felcher’s plans to eradicate the flying rat, and decided it was in their best interest to flee, though I would suspect there were plenty of the other kind of rats lurking behind those walls dressed in patent leather shoes and carrying attaché cases.
end
Pigeons have been getting a bad rap lately from City Hall. One Council Member in particular, by the name of Simcha Felder has it out for our feathered friends. He’s gone to great lengths in this regard and has even published a legislative report entitled Curbing the Pigeon Conundrum. In this report Council Member Felder proposes policy recommendations intended to reduce the pigeon population in the city of New York by utilizing hawks for killing pigeons, imposing a $1000 fine on people caught feeding the birds, and interfering with their reproductive systems by way of pigeon birth control pills.
This was a hard pill for me to swallow when I first read about it in the Daily News, and for a moment there I thought I was reading The Onion. But this was reality and later, on the local TV news was Felder again, surrounded by an entourage, giving a press conference on the evils of the flying rat, and the necessity to rid society of the winged vermin. He proposed himself the new Pigeon Czar. It felt like a new dawn was rising in New York City. There are lots of problems in our town, and murder was just one of them, but at least we were going to get the pigeon issue licked. I should have felt some kind of hope but in fact it rather put me off my breakfast, so I left that and went outside for a walk instead.
Outside, on the streets of New York, I walked by a few pigeons. They were pecking at the hard cement. They didn’t seem too threatening to me, and not at all as diseased as some of the bags of puss carrying themselves around on two legs and in business suits. In fact, they exuded a calm quiet dignity which I found inspiring. In some small way, those birds cheered me up. So what if I tossed them a few crumbs of bread once in a rare while. What harm would that bring? Then I thought of Simcha Felder. Heir Simcha Felder, who would like to slap a $1000 dollar fine on me for a mere act of kindness. What the fuck kind of bug crawled up his ass? It seemed stupid, but in light of all the stupidity we are faced with on a daily basis, it seemed to make some brutal sense. Besides, what could I do about it? It was my day off after all, and the Giants were playing the Cowboys on TV, and the hope of seeing the Cowboys get mauled was enough to get me through the day.
I didn’t think much about the pigeon thing for the rest of the week but last Saturday morning as I was watching NY 1 News, I got word that there would be a rally at noon in front of City Hall in protest of Felder’s anti-pigeon proposals. I decided to grab my camera and head on down to see what kind of people would show up.
There were about fifty people gathered in front of City Hall with banners and speakers at a podium, as well as members of the press. There were representatives from PETA, City Wildlife Alliance, Urban Wildlife Coalition, and others.
One speaker stated “do you want your taxes to go up, of course not. Think about it we’re now going to have a pigeon czar. Let’s assume that’s an assistant commissioner and that is $100,000 a year plus benefits. Commissioner has to have a couple of assistants and secretaries. We’re looking at three quarters of a million dollars by the time you pay salary and benefits. This is just to staff the office now you want to feed these birds everyday during the breeding season which for pigeons is 365 days per year with O Vatrol P (to maintain birth control) and the preliminary best guess is about $600,000 per year.
There were a lot of angry people about and lots of flyers being passed around. One flyer explained how a pigeon named Cher Ami won the Congressional Medal of Honor during World War 2 by saving 8000 allied troops and 100,000 civilians after the US artillery began unleashing a massive artillery attack on the U.S. Army’s 77th Division after the battalion got trapped behind enemy lines. A soldier attached a message to their carrier pigeon that read “Our artillery is dropping a barrage on us. For heaven’s sake, stop it!”
A historical account of the incident by the writer Andrew Blechman in his book Pigeons: The Fascinating Saga of the World’s Most Revered and Reviled Bird reads “the soldier uncupped his hands and watched the bird flap its wings and gain altitude. The Germans also saw the pigeon and trained their rifles on it. A hail of bullets whizzed through the air and several hit Cher Ami. He quickly lost altitude and plummeted toward the ground. But moments before crashing, the bird somehow managed to spread his wings again and start climbing, higher and higher, until he was out of rifle range. Twenty minutes later and back on friendly terrain, Cher Ami landed at headquarters. A soldier ran to the bird and found him lying on its back, covered in blood. One eye and part of the cranium had been blown away , and its breast had been ripped open. A silver canister containing the Lost Battalion’s desperate plea dangled from a few tendons – all that remained of the birds severed leg. Bewildered, the soldier rushed the message to his commanding officer. The American artillery fell silent, and the last remains of the Lost Battalion were saved. The stuffed tattered remains of Cher Ami can be seen today , still standing on one leg, at the Smithsonian Institute in Washington, D.C.”
After the last speaker I wandered off from the crowd, looking about the area to see if I could spot any pigeons but I couldn’t spot a single bird. Maybe they got wind of Felcher’s plans to eradicate the flying rat, and decided it was in their best interest to flee, though I would suspect there were plenty of the other kind of rats lurking behind those walls dressed in patent leather shoes and carrying attaché cases.
end